| | | | | | | | ARI | BEU | CIN | DAY | DEB | JER | KEN | MEX | MIS | PUK | REG | TAC | Team Index | Draft History | Starters: Positional - Pitchers | Registers: Batters - Pitchers | Leaders: Batters - Pitchers |  | Cincinnati Juggernaut Pitching Staff Chart |
| Year | Starting Pitchers | Closer | Bullpen | 2013 74-56 | Dake 8-10, 4.20 | Ottman 13-6, 4.44 | Machado 13-8, 3.43 | Barros 3-5, 5.64 | Padua 3-1, 5.40 | Roberts 17 SV, 3.97 | Colome 53 G, 2.98 | Roberts 44 G, 3.97 | Vaccaro 39 G, 3.15 | 2014 57-73 | Rael 13-8, 3.05 | Lepley 9-15, 4.96 | Edgar 6-4, 2.49 | Dake 2-8, 8.07 | Padua 2-2, 4.32 | Hernandez 18 SV, 3.38 | Colome 49 G, 4.11 | Murphy 39 G, 2.49 | Hernandez 34 G, 3.38 | 2015 69-61 | Barros 7-10, 6.00 | Lepley 10-9, 4.09 | Hendon 13-6, 3.37 | Edgar 10-9, 3.62 | Pagano 6-7, 5.35 | Grinder 31 SV, 3.74 | Cruz 52 G, 3.06 | Rubino 46 G, 3.94 | Grinder 44 G, 3.74 | 2016 43-87 | Cox 6-15, 4.66 | Hendon 9-13, 4.26 | Pagano 5-16, 6.12 | Lepley 0-20, 7.88 | Gómez 4-8, 4.58 | Regis 5 SV, 3.67 | Hernandez 58 G, 5.09 | Regis 41 G, 3.67 | Bumpers 34 G, 5.12 | 2017 62-68 | Barros 9-10, 4.29 | Rael 10-6, 3.83 | Vaccaro 6-8, 3.83 | Zavala 4-5, 4.43 | Hendon 4-7, 4.67 | Young 13 SV, 2.25 | Rubino 44 G, 2.81 | Bumpers 30 G, 4.27 | Castillo 28 G, 3.40 | 2018 67-63 | Edgar 12-9, 3.75 | Hendon 10-8, 3.97 | Vaccaro 8-7, 5.00 | Ingram 5-8, 4.74 | Barros 5-5, 4.48 | Castaneda 18 SV, 1.47 | Murphy 35 G, 3.88 | Castaneda 29 G, 1.47 | Vaccaro 26 G, 5.00 | 2019 50-80 | Barros 7-14, 4.36 | Vidrio 9-14, 4.53 | Young 9-7, 3.43 | Gómez 5-10, 5.13 | Vaccaro 2-10, 6.02 | Thornton 25 SV, 4.71 | Thornton 39 G, 4.71 | Wason 33 G, 6.13 | Freeze 31 G, 5.06 | 2020 69-61 | Quintana 13-11, 4.55 | Vidrio 13-10, 4.65 | Fuentes 6-10, 6.42 | Sterling 10-11, 4.53 | Young 11-7, 6.06 | Thornton 24 SV, 2.28 | Freeze 47 G, 4.96 | Cruz 44 G, 4.67 | Thornton 40 G, 2.28 | | Top 5 pitchers in Games Started, Top pitcher in Saves and Top 3 pitchers in Games | |